You have options. The hard part is that there are several, and which one fits you depends on how the debt got there rather than on how much it is.
Pick the wrong one and you can lose months. Some requests get sent straight back without being looked at.
Book a free call to go through the notice. We read the bill and list the tax years to check first. The call does not commit you to hire us.
First, a word about where you are in the process
If the IRS is already taking money or has filed a lien, you may be in a collection appeal. That has its own deadlines and they are short.
In one of those hearings, called a Collection Due Process hearing, you can only discuss whether you owe the amount, or how much, under limited circumstances. IRS: Collection due process FAQs.
So the amount is often not something you can argue in the room you are already standing in. That is why this page exists.
For our clients, we track the notice deadline and prepare the response that fits. With their authority, we handle the IRS contact. Do not let the date pass while seeking help.
The three ways to reopen what you owe
When the hearing cannot consider the amount, the IRS names three routes to reopen it. IRS: Collection due process FAQs.
- Pay the amount in full and file a claim for refund
- Request an audit reconsideration
- File an Offer in Compromise, Doubt as to Liability
They are not interchangeable. The third one is where people start and should usually finish.
Route 1: pay it, then claim it back
You pay the amount due in full, then file a claim for a refund. If the IRS disallows the claim, you have the right to appeal at that point. IRS: Collection due process FAQs.
That is a real option. It is also the one that asks the most of you up front, because you are paying something you do not think you owe.
If you go that way and the claim is disallowed, there is a clock. You have 2 years from the date of the notice of claim disallowance to file a refund suit, and Appeals looking at your disallowed claim does not extend that 2 years. It can be extended by mutual agreement. IRS Publication 5, District Court and the U.S. Court of Federal Claims.
Book a free call about a refund claim. We read the payment record and any denial letter with you, then mark the dates that matter.
Route 2: audit reconsideration
This is the route for a debt that came out of an audit. It also covers a return the IRS filed for you when you did not file one. IRS Publication 3598.
The IRS lists the reasons you might ask for one.
- You did not appear for your audit
- You moved and did not get the IRS’s letters
- You have information to present that you did not provide during the original audit
- You disagree with the assessment from the audit
What makes the IRS accept it
The IRS lists what makes a request acceptable.
- You submit information the IRS has not considered before
- You filed a return after the IRS completed a return for you
- You believe the IRS made a computational or processing error in assessing your tax
- The tax debt is unpaid, or credits are denied
That third one is worth noticing: a straightforward arithmetic or processing error is on the list in its own right.
But do not read it as a way round the documents. Publication 3598’s own first step says to verify that your records that support your case is new information that has not been presented before. IRS Publication 3598. The IRS’s collection pages put it as a requirement: you must submit new information it did not previously consider. IRS: Collection due process FAQs.
For our clients, we prepare the audit-reconsideration request. They provide the records the IRS has not seen; we set out the disputed items and file the request.
Three things the IRS says will stop it
The IRS will not accept an audit reconsideration request if any of these is true.
- You already agreed to pay the amount by signing something. A Form 906 Closing Agreement, a compromise agreement, or a Form 870-AD with the Appeals office
- What you owe comes from final partnership item adjustments under TEFRA, the Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act
- The US Tax Court, or another court, has issued a final determination on your tax liability
That first one catches people who signed something years ago to make a problem go away.
And one that sends you elsewhere rather than stopping you
If you have already paid the amount in full, this is not your route, but it is not a dead end either. You file a formal claim instead, on Form 1040-X. IRS Publication 3598.
The good news on timing
There is no deadline. You can ask any time after the examination assessment has been made on your account, while the tax remains unpaid. IRS Publication 3598.
The IRS does not require a special form, though it recommends Form 12661, Disputed Issue Verification, to explain what you disagree with. Documentation has to come with the request. IRS Publication 3598.
Do not send original documents. They will not be returned. IRS Publication 3598.
Book a free call to go through the documents. We sort them by tax year and list the evidence still needed for the request.
For our clients, we request the IRS transcripts with their authority. We read what was assessed and match it to the audit records.
While they look at it
When the IRS receives your records it may delay collection activity. It may also resume collection if your records does not support your position and you do not respond to requests for more information within 30 calendar days. IRS Publication 3598.
And if you already have an installment agreement, you must keep making the payments. IRS Publication 3598.
Book a free call if the IRS asks for more information. We read its request with you and match each question to the records needed. Keep making any required installment payments.
Route 3: the offer form, and why it is usually last
This one is Form 656-L, Offer in Compromise, Doubt as to Liability. It exists where there is a genuine dispute about the existence of, or the amount of, the correct tax debt under the law. You do not have to dispute the whole bill. It is for a legitimate doubt that you owe part or all of the debt. IRS Form 656-L.
A note on which form. The IRS’s own collection due process page still points readers at Form 656-B here. The current 656-B booklet sends doubt as to liability cases to Form 656-L. Use 656-L. IRS Form 656-B.
Now the part almost nobody is told.
The IRS would rather you did not file it
Form 656-L opens with an eleven-question check. Ten of the eleven answers tell you not to file it, and send you somewhere else instead. IRS Form 656-L, DATL Pre-Qualifier Assessment.
Here is that list in plain terms. If any of these is your situation, the offer form is the wrong paperwork.
| Your situation | What the IRS says to do instead |
|---|---|
| You cannot afford to pay, or paying in full would cause a hardship | A different offer, on Form 656, in the 656-B booklet |
| Something was reported wrong on the return you filed | Amend the return, for example Form 1040-X |
| The IRS filed the return for you | Send in a signed original return |
| An audit created the debt | Request audit reconsideration |
| You only want a penalty reduced or removed | Ask for penalty relief |
| You disagree with an adjustment for unreported income | Respond to the CP2000 notice |
| Your Forms 941, 943, 944, 945, 1040 or Schedule H and the Social Security data disagree | Send a corrected W-2 and/or W-3, or a corrected Form 941 or 943. The IRS adds “etc.”, so that list is open |
| You do not think you owe the Affordable Care Act or marketplace tax | File Form 1040-X |
| You are submitting an SS-8 worker classification determination | Follow the SS-8 instructions |
| It is only about an injured spouse | Form 8379, Injured Spouse Allocation |
IRS Form 656-L, DATL Pre-Qualifier Assessment.
Only the eleventh answer leads to the form. It is for someone who does not believe they owe all or part of the debt and has already pursued any of the applicable alternatives above. IRS Form 656-L.
One more gate sits on that answer. If you do not have a tax debt, you are not eligible for an offer until you have received a balance due notice. IRS Form 656-L.
For our clients, we prepare and file the request their case supports. We check the IRS route before preparing an offer that may be returned.
If you file it anyway, out of order
The IRS is explicit. Unless your debt is a Trust Fund Recovery Penalty or a Personal Liability Excise Tax, you should pursue those other options first. IRS Form 656-L.
And if another IRS process is already running on the same tax debt, you have to let it finish.
- If you are already working with the IRS, or responding to a notice about the same issue, you must resolve that first
- If another IRS function is addressing the liability, audit reconsideration for example, you must wait until that process is complete
- Failing to resolve outstanding issues may result in the IRS returning the offer without being considered
Book a free call to check what is already underway. We put the IRS letters in date order and compare them with the unresolved requests.
Who cannot use it at all
You do not qualify if any of these applies. IRS Form 656-L.
- The liability has been settled by a final court decision or judgment
- The assessed tax is based on current law
- You are in an open bankruptcy. You may file once the bankruptcy is completed or discharged
- You are paying or owe restitution to the Department of Justice. The IRS has no authority to compromise restitution assessments
- You already have an accepted offer for the same tax year and the same tax debt, on either of two specific bases: doubt as to collectibility, or doubt as to liability
- You have a deactivated Individual Taxpayer Identification Number. That has to be sorted out first
- You have made an election under section 965(i) for the liability in question. The IRS will not compromise those. A liability deferred under section 965(h)(1) is compromised only in the few cases set out in the form
For our clients, we check the offer conditions before preparing Form 656-L. If a listed restriction rules it out, we say so and do not prepare that offer.
The mechanics, if it is genuinely your route
- You must explain in writing why all or part of the debt is wrong, with records that support your case. Without it the offer is returned without being considered
- Your offer should reflect what you believe you actually owe, and it must be $1.00 or more. A $0 offer is returned without processing
- Do not send any payment with it. There is no deposit and no application fee
- If you cannot reconstruct your books and records, you must give an explanation that establishes reasonable doubt
Two trade-offs worth knowing before you sign
Submitting the offer costs you something, and the form says so in its terms.
- It gives the IRS more time to assess, and it is more than a year. The new deadline becomes your current one, plus the whole time your offer is pending, plus one more year
- That longer deadline applies if the offer is rejected, returned or terminated, or if you withdraw it
- And you cannot really refuse that. The IRS may not consider your offer at all if you decline to waive the period, or if you give only a limited waiver
- The collection clock pauses while they look. The period for collecting the debt is suspended while the offer is pending. It stays suspended for 30 days after a rejection, and while a rejection is with the Independent Office of Appeals
- If it is accepted, the argument is over. Once the IRS accepts in writing, you have no right to contest the amount, in court or otherwise
- A lien can still be filed. The IRS may file a Notice of Federal Tax Lien while the offer is being considered
Book a free call before signing an offer. We go through the waiver terms with you and mark the rights and time periods they affect.
If you agree you owe it but cannot pay
That is a different problem with a different form, and it is worth saying plainly because the two get mixed up constantly.
If you agree you owe the tax but cannot pay it, do not file Form 656-L. That situation uses Form 656, in the 656-B booklet. IRS Form 656-L.
You also cannot run both at once. You cannot submit a doubt as to liability offer and a separate offer based on inability to pay at the same time. Send both and the inability-to-pay one is returned without being considered, and any initial payment with it is not returned. IRS Form 656-L.
The IRS says it is in your best interest to settle any disagreement about whether the debt is valid before filing on inability to pay. IRS Form 656-L.
For our clients, we prepare the financial case for a payment solution when the amount owed is settled. They provide income, expense and asset records; we assemble the proposal that fits.
Who can help you with this
You can do all of it yourself. If you want someone to act for you, the IRS needs a signed authorisation: Form 2848 for representation, or Form 8821 if you only want someone to receive your information. Form 8821 does not let them represent you in a collection matter. IRS Form 656-L.
You may not need to pay for help. A Low Income Taxpayer Clinic can represent people on a low income before the IRS or in court, and can help people who speak English as a second language. Any service an LITC provides must be free or for a small fee. The list is in IRS Publication 4134. IRS Form 656-L.
The Taxpayer Advocate Service is independent inside the IRS. It offers free help in three situations.
- Your tax problem is causing financial difficulty
- You have tried to resolve it with the IRS and been unable to
- You believe an IRS system, process or procedure is not working as it shouldIRS Form 656-L.
Book a free call if you want help taking the next step. We read the case record with you and list the work that IRS representation would cover. A free or low-cost clinic may also fit.
What to gather before you call anyone
- Every letter the IRS has sent, in date order
- The examination report if there was an audit, usually Form 4549
- Anything that supports your side, including documents the examiner never saw
- A note of what you have already sent the IRS and when
- Whether any part of the amount has been paid, because that changes which route is open
Where this leaves you
If you think the IRS has it wrong, the question is not “how do I fight this”. It is “how did this debt get created”, because that decides the route.
An audit created it, so audit reconsideration. Something on your own return was wrong, so amend it. A penalty only, so penalty relief. Already paid in full, so a refund claim. And the offer form at the end of that list rather than the start of it.
If you want a second pair of eyes on the letter before you file anything, IRS Help offers a free 30 minute consultation. Bring the notice. There is no pressure, and we read your IRS records before anyone commits to anything. You can reach us through the contact page.
This article is general information about federal tax procedure. It is not legal or tax advice about your situation. Which route is open to you depends on the notice you received and your own facts.
Schedule your free consultation
